Valve THD analysis

Measuring triode linearity

Today decided to do a quick distortion test of on a sample of a variety of different valves. All either triodes or triode-strapped pentodes/tetrodes. As per my previous tests, distortion was measured at +22.22dBu (10 Vrms) at the output of the valve in common-cathode mode. Valves were loaded with the CCS I use in my curve tracer. The operating points were quickly optimised at hand, so I’m sure there may be some better operating points for some of the valves below which may improve their overall THD. If you have any suggestions, please let me know!

valve thd analysis table — Tested valves for THD

Need to retake these measures as the soundcard interface got damaged and results are showing significant distortion

Interesting to see in the chart above, that 6e5p and 6C45p are the best ones. This is in line with their reputation as drivers as they are capable of swinging many volts and producing very low distortion. In terms of harmonics I noticed that 6e5P provides a richer H3 and H5 as being a triode-strapped valve, whereas the 6c45p provide a dominant H2.

Also good to see that my favourite 46, 4P1L and 6CB5A (all triode-strapped) are very linear with anode currents of 40mA (with the exception of 46 as I measured THD on a previous operating point used for transconductance measurement). I should retake the 46 and drive it harder, I’m sure it will perform better at higher current.

Surprised with the results of the 6N6P-I. Was expecting this one a bit better, but perhaps it’s the pulse version distortion, so may need to get hold of an 6N6P and compare the results.

Update:
It looks like I blew up Pete Millett’s interface after measuring THD in float mode and exceeding the 10Vrms limit in this mode. Therefore measures such as 26, CX301a and others are not accurate. When testing 26 with my Ferrograph test set it came out to be 0.05%…
Stay tune until I repair the unit!

46 THD analysis

GM tester modified today to add an option to disconnect the CCS bypass capacitor so can drive the valve with an external signal and measure THD from output in common-cathode mode. The input is calibrated to produce 10Vrms (22.22dBu) at the anode and then signal is fed into the PC through the Pete Millet’s interface:

Did some sample tests with a set of lovely globe CX301a achieving THDs from 0.27% to 0.35%.

When looking at a driver valve such as 46 (triode-strapped) got THD values of around 0.05-0.09% for good valves. When picked up the faulty one I had discovered yesterday with the curve tracer, the THD shown to be 0.20% and over 0.35% in the worst one.

Need to retake these measures as the soundcard interface got damaged and results are showing significant distortion

The PC generates a low distortion sine wave which is fed into the valve grid through the input capacitor. This is the same setup used for the transconductance test. The CCS in the anode is unbypassed to ensure the anode signal is not shunted to ground. The output is then taken out through the output PIO capacitor and fed back into the PC input adapter (Pete Millett’s sound card interface). Audiotester is used then to measure THD at 1kHz.

Cunningham CX301a

These RCA Cunningham CX-301a have short pins so had to use an external socket to trace the curves. They look really nice and the pair I got measure nearly 100%!

Measuring Transconductance (Gm)

GM tester jig circuit

After a bit of work, got the transconductance jig working fine. Made an obvious omission which was not bypassing the CCS. The CCS present a very high impedance in AC to the circuit, therefore not developing the current variation on the measuring resistor. Bypassed by an electrolytic presents a path to ground.

Updated 6e5P SPICE model

Having fixed the bias offset problem in my tester (actually my oscilloscope). I took again the curves this evening to get a better model….

If you want to read how did I manage to get here, please read this post

6e5p bias fixed — 6e5p triode strapped curves (offset fixed so grid voltages are fine now!)

Measuring valve transconductance

Today I breadboarded the CCS I will use for the transconductance tester jig which is an addition to my curve tracer:

Bias circuit is a classic from fixed bias amplifiers. I had the 80V available from the curve tracer circuit. The meter is an external panel AC voltmeter which is a trueRMS meter that will measure accurately the 1kHz signal.

The MOSFET CCS is a simple cascoded which can help setting the valve current and operating point. I source it with my bench variable HT power supply, which also helps in setting out the operating point.

We know that we need to have a small AC signal in the grid to increase the accuracy of the Gm test as the transconductance is given by:

$G_{m}=\frac{\Delta I_{a}}{\Delta V_{g}} _{\Delta V_{a}=0}$

So can’t feed with 1Vrms, so will use 100mVrms. If a valve has a transconductance of 1mA/V, then the variance in the anode current will be of 100uA (rms). This represents a challenge to measure accurately using an anode resistor of 10 ohms for example since the developed AC voltage across the resistor will be 1mV (rms). Therefore we will use an anode resistor of 100 ohms which will help capturing small transconductance values as this one.

Edit:

Found that the CCS bypass was omitted in my first circuit. Also the sensing resistor was reduced to 10 ohms to accommodate the AC true-rms meter I have. See updates on this post here